Login   |   Register   |   

REF'S DECISIONS?

Started by: GOLDEN BEAR (6780) 

Wow what another incredible howler tonight at anfield , the award of a penalty the first on on lallana, i realise the old saying ( look in tommorrow;s paper ) IF that was a penalty then all i can say is god help us when they start using the video replays, plus it was that ref who since christmas has made more wrong decisions than right ones .

First he should have booked LALLANA for the funniest of wriggle type dives iv'e seen for a long time ,then restart with a free kick to Everton but he let it go but thats sport for you .
Across at OLD TRAFFORD did not see it but by all accounts united had all the possession but had to wait until 84 minutes , then the other from the big lad LAKUKU ON 90 MINS so both REDS are in the bag for the 4th round . BUT have to say the standards of refereeing does appear to be degenerating ,what you think??????

Started: 6th Jan 2018 at 02:57

Posted by: paul mcnamara (1111) 

Only saw the first half as up early on days today GB. However, Holgate definitely manhandled Lallana and prevented him from getting to the ball, his dive was late and possibly unnecessary as I think the ref may have given it anyway. Holgate should have walked for the assault on Firmino, that could have caused serious injury. Rooney was too fired up and could also have been sent off for a number of bad tackles. Just a neutral observation.

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 07:44

Posted by: chatty (9774)

Not seen that incident GB, but someone on the radio pointed out Big Sam was more than happy with the penalty decision they got in the league game with Liverpool the other week and this was of a similar vein?

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 08:16

Posted by: laughing gravy (inactive)

chatty i bet your very happy winning the FA cup,well you must have done seeing that little big nose was PRANCING again after beating the MIGHTY DERBY WITH VERY LATE GOALS TOO

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 08:47

Posted by: chatty (9774)

I feel your pain I really do, but you must let it go, all the angst everytime United win can't be doing your health any good.

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 09:32

Posted by: paul (3014) 

Holgate definitely should have walked. I've seen softer tackles in the Ken Gee cup!

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 16:31

Posted by: bridger (inactive)

Rubbish.

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 16:34

Posted by: grimshaw (4023) 

Dive of the week has been hazards v arsenal in gaining a penalty for Chelsea

I can understand fully Wengers anger .

The slightest contact will see hazard go to earth.

England beware this coming summer .

Replied: 6th Jan 2018 at 21:55

Posted by: GOLDEN BEAR (6780) 

Paul Mcnamara:You are probably right Paul i have looked at it again and on further viewing i think the pen was just right. But i still believe that the problem is that the slightest of decisions these days are so blown up with the tv pundits ,disecting every move /tackle slow-motion it does give at time's, a bias view. Also paul what do you think about the onset of video ref's when they come in are they going to help or not .

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 15:44

Posted by: GOLDEN BEAR (6780) 

Chatty: That guy ( lg) why does he mention about United scoring late when his club have been scoring one or two very ,very late goals also this season ,so what on earth is he on about? From Wigan Athletics point yesterday Bourne mouth equalised in 90 + 2 isn't that harsh ,i mean a game from what i have learned last's until the final whistle no matter how long that be.

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 15:51

Posted by: laughing gravy (inactive)

uniteds team cost 100s of millions more than derbys yet it too until the 70 odd minutes to score LAUGHABLE..

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 16:13

Posted by: chatty (9774)

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 17:27

Posted by: blackrodweaver (628) 

Refs do a thankless job in football these days never have their decisions been anallised more.
ref sees it once makes a call , pundits view it from 7 different angles in slow motion and decided hes made a howler, not fair really.Then not all of them agree.

offside how did a linesman not see from 35yds away that a forward's left foot was offside. ridiculous.

yes they make bad decisions will VAR make it better , they will still disagree mark my words

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 20:27

Posted by: paul (3014) 

Not 100% sure Golden Bear, but it seems to work OK in Rugby matches!

Replied: 7th Jan 2018 at 20:59

 

Note: You must login to use this feature.

If you haven't registered, why not join now?. Registration is free.